The Potomac Highlands Watershed School 

Stream Cleaner Environmental Forum 2007

Points of View & Thoughtful Questions - Farmers

If you landed here via a search engine, this page is part of Cacapon Institute's web school.  Our home page is here.

 

Farmer POV & TQ Navigation

 rebel racing redneck ranchers CBJL Potomac Paints Let er' roll  MJ's Farm

Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Caring Farmers of America

The First Rich Farmers   Tenacious D Farmer Friends of the Bay

Pitchfork of Justice  the farmers  Future Farmers of Jefferson County

Sustainable Futures    dgaf08  Freaky Farmer

The supreme amazing people that do good stuff    RS Farmers

Hampshire Rednecks  Robbie Jennifer Justin   LC

Navigation to other POV pages

 Bay Ecosystem  •  Recreation/Tourism  •  Farmers  •  Watermen  •  Local Governments

Homeowner  •   Developer  ▪  Chesapeake Bay Program  ▪  Others

Comments to All Farmers

 

From:      Team Happy Fish! North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/28/2007

                                                                                                                            11:32:00 AM

         Most farmer stakeholders (this is especially targeted to the Future Farmers of

         Jefferson County) feel that becuase they are making small steps toward progress, they

         have made enough of a contribution to the Bay's clean-up.  It is wonderful that farmers

         are using bio-fuel but that simply is not enough!! Everyone is appreciative of the work

         of the farmer's; we are grateful for the crops and the meat but this won't matter when

         the entire Bay ecosystem shrivels and dies due to pollution!  Farmers need to make sure

         animals stay out of tributaries, they need to construct riparian buffers, and they need to

          reduce the use of fertilizers.  Countour and no-till farming can also be utilized.  My

         question is this:  do farmers truly feel that biofuel alone can save the Bay?  We need

         more help!

 

Farmers

rebel racing Hampshire H.S. / Moore

Monday, March 05, 2007

1:20 PM

Farmers are important because we grow most of the food for our area.  The problem is that the fertilizers we use on our fields are floating in to the river. Also the up river counties are polluting the water that we water our crops with. I say that  if we could stop dumping so much toxic waste in the river. I could also help the counties down river from us by growing more grass in the drainage ditches so it will hold off more of the fertilizers and things that can be pollutant to the river and the animals in the river and the ones who drink out of the river. I really hope that people can help me and my fellow farmers to help clean up our acts.

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

   From:    Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               6:11:00 AM

          As a farmer I don't agree with your comment that farmers are "dumping toxic wastes

          into the river". What type of wastes are you refering to and where did you get your

          information?

 

   From:    Conkreat Jungul Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:25:00 AM

          I agree with the fact that farmers are a very important part of our economy and how

          they contribute to pollution in the river.  I am wondering what your views are on fixing

          this problem.  You very clearly state what the problems are but I'm wondering what

          specific ways farmers can improve the quality of the river and reduce pollution.  Maybe

           discuss some BMP's (Best Mangagement Practices)and explain how they will help reduce

           pollution.  Thanks for listening to my suggestions and questions.

 

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:36:00 AM

          You mentioned that farmers dump toxic waste in the bay and that they shouldn't.  What

          specific "toxic waste" are you referring to and what should farmers do with this waste?

 

  From:    diligent developers =] North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/28/2007

                                                                                                                            11:59:00 AM

         You mentioned that your fertizlers are flowing into the river but what do you suggest

         you do to stop that? As far as toxic dumping what toxins are you dumping? THe

         buffering around the rivers is a good idea but a better idea would be to invest in a bmp.

         It would pay off more in the end. Perhaps you should research a few and find one that

         best suits your farm. =] this site will show you where all the nutrients are coming from

         and you can better choose a bmp from it. [

         http://cacaponinstitute.com/PHSWR%20Chats/WVPTSchesbaymodel%20Graphs.htm ]

         also, you can look at some bmp's from this site. [

         http://cacaponinstitute.com/WVPTS%20bmps.htm ] it includes more links to more bmp

         sites. =] k.thanks.

 

 

Farmers

redneck ranchers Hampshire H.S. / Moore

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

1:18 PM

We are important to every country in the world because we are a main supplier of food for people and animals in the world.

We are one of the most polluting sources but we also need our nutrients for our crops but with a little more money we can help to prevent the pollution in the water.

If we could raise more money we could help solve the pollution problem but we cant do it on our own. if we could get help from our community we wouldn't have such a big polluting problem.

We recommend that we could not run our farm land all the way to the river bank. we could leave 10 yards of just green area and let it grow into tall grass to help stop our minerals from going into the water.

We could raise our prices that way we would have more money for a solution for the pollution and if we could get a tax break for land that is not in use that would also help.

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

   From:    Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               6:21:00 AM

          How are you proposing to raise your own prices?  Unless you sell directly to the

          consumer, most commodity prices are controlled by economics.  Also, if the prices are

          raised to high, would your product sell?

 

   From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:25:00 AM

          We acknowledge that you are trying to find a reasonable solution to limiting pollution,

          however, we are concerned about the source of funding for these projects.  If you raise

           the prices for your crops, then consumers will buy cheaper produce elsewhere.  So if

          you did receive funding, then how would you use it to stop pollution?

 

   From:    T.A.L.K About the Bay Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:46:00 AM

              Have you thought about different best management practices to help filter the

          pollution that comes from your crops? There are many different grants and government

          money out there for farmers to try different BMPs. Also, if you raise your prices

          couldn't that hurt your farm's income rather than help it if other farmers keep their

          prices low?

 

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:52:00 AM

          You said that you hoped to raise money from your community.  Why would any of the

          other stakeholder groups in your community want to contribute?  What is in it for them?

           As a waterman, I don't have the extra money to give to farmers.  Would it be possible to

           suggest a trade off or some way that other groups will be happy too?

 

   From:    Chesapeake Industrial Corporation Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               7:51:00 AM

          In response to your first statement, you need some specifics as to saying who "we" is

          and some data to support the fact that you are a "main supplier of food" around the

          entire world.  Also, a riparian water buffer is the only BMP that you discussed.  There

          are many other BMP's that farmers could implement to improve the quality of the water. 

          If you are planning on raising your prices, you must take into account supply and

          demand and think about how the consumers will not purchase products that are

          overpriced. 

 

  From:    Happy Campers North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/22/2007

                                                                                                                            11:24:00 AM

         I have a question, how do you think the consumers will respond to the raise in prices?

         Also, in addition to planting grass to prevent runoff, as a suggestion, you could plant

         trees as well to form a riparian buffer.

  From:    Business of the Bay North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/22/2007

                                                                                                                            12:09:00 PM

         Your ideas good but just raiseing the prices could be alittle hard. Also you could try and

         use a more environmentally friendy fertilizer and less of it if at all posssible, but if you

         could find a way to get the prices up to make more improvements than that would be

         great.

  From:    Team Awesome Broadway H.S. / Rissler

                                                                                                                              3/22/2007

                                                                                                                             12:17:00 PM

         How would receiving more money solve the pollution problem?  It doesn't take an

         exuberant amount of financial resources to leave areas around riverbanks uncultivated.

          It may take more than " 10 yards of just green area" to filter out "minerals", sediment

            and other non-point sources of pollution (manure).

 

Farmer POV & TQ Navigation

rebel racing redneck ranchers CBJL Potomac Paints Let er' roll  MJ's Farm

Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Caring Farmers of America

The First Rich Farmers   Tenacious D Farmer Friends of the Bay

Pitchfork of Justice  the farmers  Future Farmers of Jefferson County

Sustainable Futures    dgaf08  Freaky Farmer

The supreme amazing people that do good stuff    RS Farmers

Hampshire Rednecks  Robbie Jennifer Justin   LC

Back to Top

 

Farmers

CBJL East Hardy H.S. / Halterman

Tuesday, March 06, 2007

1:38 PM

I am a farmer. I raise corn for my family. I live 12 miles from the stream so I do everything I can to keep the water clean. I raise wheat fo the community. The community thanks me and I do all I can to keep the Chesapeak Bay clean. I try not to use too much fertilizer on my farm so I don't polute the Chesapeak Bay. I use grass buffer and forest buffer around my farm.

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

   From:    T.A.L.K About the Bay Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               6:21:00 AM

          Since you don't use fertilizers, what do you do to bring nutrients back into the soil. Do

          you use crop rotation or contour stripping?

          Also, what other solutions besides the buffers could all farmers use to help keep

          pollution from spreading into nearby water sources?

 

         Response from  CBJL East Hardy H.S. / Halterman

                                                                                                                                  3/26/2007

                                                                                                                                 1:10:00 PM

                What do you think we use. We use cow and chicken POOP amd just pray it don't go into the

                 river. Whatever you want to use like reparian buffers.

 

   From:    Chesapeake Homeowners Association Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:29:00 AM

          You're a farmer. You raise food for your family.  I'm very glad that you do what you can

           to help the communities' water supply.  Have you looked into any government plans that

          could give you extra money to further help your plans to keep the water supply clean?  It

           would really benefit you and your community.

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:50:00 AM

          You mention you are doing everything you can to help protect the Bay: What are some

          specific practices you are using on your farm to protect the Bay? Are you using any

          BMP's?

  From:    diligent developers =] North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/22/2007

                                                                                                                            12:00:00 PM

         as a farmer, i understand it is your job to provide people with crops, as well as their

         animals. although, it is important you should take into consideration the community and

         how they are going to respond to your actions. if you raise your prices, which from what

          ive read other responses, you would have to directly sell in order to accomplish, people

         will find others to buy from that are cheaper. this is only going to make it harder for

         you. maybe in addition to what you are already doing you could call and figure out a new

         mangagement strategy that would even better help the environment perhaps?

 

 

 

Farmers

 

Potomac Paints Hampshire H.S. / Moore

March 12, 2007

7:36 AM

We are very important to the community because we supply almost all the food around the world.  We know that we are one of the main sources of pollution of streams and rivers, and we are trying hard to reduce or even prevent this.   

We could prevent pollution from entering streams by using manure from our livestock instead of using chemicals.  This would save us money to buy more important things to help other pollution problems.  We could also allow others to use the manure for fertilizer instead of just leaving it in a pile for it to wash away.

We could leave 10 to 20 yards of tall grass between the farming area and the stream or river, to help keep the minerals away from the water.  We wouldn't allow our livestock in the river or stream.  That way, they won't be able to pollute the water.

We are willing to do our part even if others do not.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

   From:    Conkreat Jungul Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:28:00 AM

          Friend, the nutrients from excess manure pollute the Bay just as badly as excess

          chemical fertilizer--the two contain the same nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorous, and

          potassium). Allowing others to use the manure for fertilizer doesn't really solve anything

           either, since, in the end, the same amount of cow poo ends up on the ground and in the

          water. Finally, 10-20 yds of space really isn't enough for a good riparian buffer.

 

   From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:37:00 AM

          Even though you plan not to allow livestock in the river, pollutants are still able to travel

          to the water through manure run-off.  Excess in manure results in higher nitrogen,

          phosphorous, and potassium concentrations in the stream, which leads to algal bloom and

          further deterioration of the stream.  Though manure may replace harmful chemicals, it

          has its own negative effects on crops.  For example, manure may grow a larger plant, but

           not necessarily more of the crop itself.  Do you have any plans to limit manure run-off?

 

   From:    Chesapeake Homeowners Association Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              7:07:00 AM

          Something that you should consider is that manure also contains nutrients, such as

          nitrogen, phosphorous, and potassium, and spreading them on your fields will create

          problems in the streams just as chemicals would. Could you give me some other methods

          that could be used to help keep our rivers clean?

 

   From:    Enigmatic Enviromentalists Broadway H.S. / Rissler

                                                                                                                               3/20/2007

                                                                                                                             12:43:00 PM

          What are you going to do about the manure getting into your water source? It will

          pollute the water if it reaches the stream. Manure will pollute just as much as chemicals

          will, but it's harder for the manure to get to the stream. Can you think of a sollution to

          cut back on the amount of manure getting into the streams?

  From:    Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                             7:32:00 AM

         Manure can be applied to fields in ways that decrease the amount of nutrients that

         runoff.  Precision fertilizing involves testing the fertilizer and the land to determine

         which areas of the field need which nutrients and how much.

        

         There are also other uses for animal wastes. Manure can be used to produce electricity,

         although it is expensive to build a digester.  The liquids and solids can be separated from

          the manure and the liquids can be used for fertilizer and the solids can be used for

         mulch or in greenhouse soil mixes.

        

         I think 10-20 yards is plenty of space for a riparian buffer. Most farmers and

         landowners aren't going to be willing the give up more land than that.

        

         Also, over applying fertilizers can damage a crop, but if the fertilizer is tested and the

         land is tested this can be prevented. Most farmers aren't going to over apply nutrients

         because fertilizer, fuel, and labor are expensive. One response states that the plant may

          grow larger, but not necessarily more of the crop itself.  Isn't the purpose of growing

         the crop to have more of the plant?  If not, please explain what you mean by this.

 

 

Farmers

 

Let er' roll Hampshire H.S. / Moore

March 12, 2007

9:18 AM

We is farmers that live near a river. we try our best to keep our water clean, so our cows dont get sick and die. And so our plant dont get dieases. We use the water that runs beside the house for everything, washing clothes, drinking, fishing, irrigating and bathing. That is why we try to keep our river clean so we dont get sick. If we have dirty and polluted water it will cost use alot, we will have to dig a well and we really dont have the money, so if you are one of the people who like mud boging in the river then I will you please think about what your doing and think about the people you are hurting. 

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

   From:    T.A.L.K About the Bay Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               6:21:00 AM

          It is great that you try to keep your river clean. What methods do you use to keep the

          water clean so that you do not get sick? As a farmer, do you have a lot of run off into

          the river, such as sediments and cow manure? What methods have you found effective

          that you may share with other farmers?

 

   From: anonymous Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               6:41:00 AM

          You are proposing to dig a well if the river water is polluted, but what about groundwater

           pollution?  Also, many farmers are in rural communities and already have wells.

 

   From:    Conkreat Jungul Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                               7:01:00 AM

          Umm...shouldn't you already have a well? I don't think that you are allowed to build a

          house without either having a well or municipal water.

          Also, though you state your reasons for being concerned with the health of your river,

          you never offer a single solution or present a way for you to contribute to the cleanup

          effort. Instead, you merely place the blame on the others who are polluting the water.

          How are you polluting the Bay and what can you do about it?

 

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              7:05:00 AM

          What are you doing to protect your farm from the polluted water coming from the river?

           How are you protecting the river from the toxins from your farm? Try to give more

          specifics.

 

   From:    Caring Farmers of America Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                               3/20/2007

                                                                                                                               8:11:00 AM

          What if moving our crops and livestock is not a soultion to the problem? Paying attention

           to the problem before it starts would be a better outcome. Moving crops would be a

          disadvantage to income for that year. You would have to turn fields, replant, and wait till

           next season for everything to grow. What would you do for income that year if you had

          to move your crops? Would you take a risk of not having enough money, or stick to

          having bad water?

 

  From:    Team Happy Fish! North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/22/2007

                                                                                                                             12:01:00 PM

         What exactly is mud boging and what is it's effect on the environment?

 

         Response  to ALL from  Let er roll Hampshire H.S. / Moore

                                                                                                                                  3/27/2007

                                                                                                                                 8:59:00 AM

                to try to keep our water clean we use water purfier and we send water saples to get tested

                to see what is in our water, so it will not harm us or our crops when we irrigerate them. We

                do not have a solution for keepen cow maunture out of our water so we will have to work

                on that, got any ideas? the olny way we could is to move our cows to a different location

                but we cant. we was have a well but we are not in a rural comunity we are dont have many

                peope that live arroud ur we have a hand dug well close to our house where we get water

 

 

 

Farmers

 

MJ's Farm Hampshire H.S. / Moore

March 12, 2007

9:24 AM

We are the MJ Farm, here in Hampshire Co.  Our job is to raise dairy cows.  We are important to the area because we supply and pasturize our own milk for many household needs.

Our farm is located on a large hill which creates problems.  All of the waste coming from our cattle, flows downhill into the streams below creating toxins which later flow into the Chesapeake area.

I think all farmers/landowners, should have a tax cut.  With the money we save from taxes, we would be able to donate it to the Chesapeake area for water purifiers.  If we would be unable to donate money for cleanliness, the ecosystem would die, and our drinking water would be contaminated.

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

   From:    Chesapeake Homeowners Association Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:45:00 AM

          There is a type of Best Management Program System (BMP's) that you could use yourself

           to help keep the cow manure from entering the water supply, it is called buffer strips. 

          You can use either Grass Buffers of Forest Buffers; these would help to catch some of

          the runoff that runs down your hill.  There are government plans that would help you pay

          for these systems as well.  The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Services and Department of

          Forestry give money to help with these processes if you apply for them.

 

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              6:47:00 AM

          You say that toxins flow from your farm and find their way into the bay.  What type of

          toxins are they?  Your P.O.V. also states that farmers/landowners should all get tax cuts.

            Where would the money come from to cover those tax cuts?

 

   From:    Chesapeake Homeowners Association Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              7:04:00 AM

          The extra sediments and nutrients that come from your farm and pollute the Chesapeake

          Bay will become a major problem in the future.  Instead of donating the money saved

          from the tax cuts maybe you should consider keeping the money saved to invest in

          buffers for your farm to stop the pollution at the source.  Tax cuts are a good idea for

          helping out farmers, but have you researched and found if there is any available grant

            money for farmers to help?

 

 

 

 

Farmers

 

Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                                   3/14/2007

                                                                                                                                  7:53:00 AM

 

Society needs to eat, plain and simple, and while we are attempting to clean up the Bay and

protect our natural resources, we also need to take into consideration the fact that farmers and

 landholders need some sort of protection as well.  We are necessary to society as suppliers of

the nation’s food and contributors to our national economy.  Modern agricultural operations are

 producing up to 100 times more than farmers did 50 years ago.  There are 185 million

livestock animals in the watershed, which is 11 times the human population.  These livestock

produce about 44 million tons of manure annually.  Most of this manure is spread as fertilizers,

 but with advances in new technology we may be able find new ways to use manure.  While only

2% of the population is directly involved in the production of food, agriculture provides a lot

of jobs to the national economy.  We rely on a good water supply and productive soils to

produce food, which is why we also support the endeavor of cleaning the Chesapeake Bay and

protecting our waterways.  However, there are limits to what we as a group can do with the

resources we have.  We as a cooperative effort want to reduce nutrient and sediment pollution

from our pastures and croplands and still remain profitable.  It will take a cooperative effort

from many stakeholders to accomplish our goals.  Instead of wasting time blaming other groups

for the problem that everyone has had a part in causing, we need to work together to fix it.

 

Many of our nutrient and sediment problems originate from waste management and from

pasture and cropland runoff.  As an industry we need to work to improve the water quality, as it

 directly and indirectly affects us in many ways.  There are many simple ways that we can

begin to improve the water quality on our farms at home by implementing best management

practices (BMP).  BMPs are techniques can be used on both rural and urban lands to improve

water quality and the profitability of the landowner.  On our fields we use many different

fertilizers to achieve high yields, but if used incorrectly these fertilizers can be very harmful

to the rivers and lead to eutrophication.  Eutrophication is when excess fertilizers cause algal

blooms.  These algal blooms block sunlight and after death bacteria use up the oxygen to

decompose them.  One BMP that we as farmers and landowners can implement to filter out

chemicals and nutrients is a riparian buffer strip. This entails planting trees or shrubs along

the edges of streams and waterways. The roots absorb excess nutrients and catch sediments

before they reach the water. Alternative water sources for livestock can also be placed in

pastures to enable farmers to fence livestock out of streams.  These methods in themselves

cannot save our bay and we must continue to find new ways to protect our water quality.

 

Another harmful effect of runoff is the large amounts of sediment that can wash into the

water from exposed fields. One way to reduce this is by using a cover crop. In this method we

can plant crops such as winter wheat, barley, or rye that can trap sediments and slow erosion. 

These crops can also be harvested for forage in the spring.  Research has also found that

feeding lower levels of nitrogen and phosphorus to livestock can reduce the amount of these

nutrients in the waste. 

 

Recently, research has been conducted to find new waste management techniques that can

reduce denitrification and find new uses for waste.  Denitrification is the release of nitrogen

into the air, decreasing the effectiveness of the fertilizer.  By covering manure pits, methane

can be harvested and used as a fuel source.  This procedure also decreases the amount of

methane, a serious greenhouse gas, released directly into the atmosphere.  Also, a separator

can divide the manure solids from the liquids, which can be applied to crops.  The solids can be

sold as a growing medium or used to add organic matter to soils.  However, these solid

separators and manure digesters are only economically feasible on large farms or in areas

where many small farms can transport manure to a central location.  Transporting manure,

however, can lead to high fuels costs and concerns about bio-security on participating farms.

 

These BMPs will not make any difference unless a large amount of farmers and landowners

decide to implement them. We can find ways to educate and inform farmers about what we can

do to help clean up the Chesapeake Bay such as having annual or biannual meetings and

educational trips to the Chesapeake Bay so that we can see first hand what we are working to

accomplish.  As landowners and farmers we can implement BMPs that reduce nutrient and

sediment runoff on agricultural land and help to increase profitability on farming operations. 

The cost of these BMPs can be partially funded by cost share programs supported by the

government and the Soil and Water Conservation District.  The cost share limit in $50,000 and

 low cost loans are available through the Department of Environmental Quality at 3% interest

on a minimum of $5,000.   The government has proposed in the 2007 Farm Bill to increase

conservation funding by $7.8 billion and provide $500 million for bio-energy technology;

while this funding has been proposed on a national level, it does not provide for section-based

financial support for areas like the Chesapeake Bay Watershed. Those involved in the Bay

cleanup need to make their point known to their congressmen so that the Bay will be a specific

concern when they decide on the distribution of the funding.

 

The Chesapeake Bay is important for recreation, fishing, and industry.  We realize we have

had a part in causing the decline of our water quality but are not solely responsible.  We need

to work collectively with other stakeholders to achieve our goals of reducing nutrient and

sediment pollution. If this can be done, these issues will be resolved at a much faster rate then

if we were to work alone. 

 

Works Cited

 

CBF's FARM BILL STRATEGY.

http://www.cbf.org/site/PageServer?pagename=act_sub_actioncenter_federal_farm_strateg

y. 2 March 2007.

 

Cost Share Programs. http://www.dof.virginia.gov/mgt/cip-summary.shtml. 2 March 2007.

Dollar, Christopher D, ed. Save the Bay. Annapolis, MD: Chesapeake Bay Foundation,

2005.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

   From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              7:37:00 AM

          When you talk about denitrification, how is methane used as fuel healthier for the

          environment than the methane released directly into the atmosphere from the cows?

          Isn't it eventually released into the atmosphere anyway?

  

                                                                                                                               3/19/2007

                                                                                                                              7:55:00 AM

          I agree that the annual meetings would be a great way to inform the farmers on the

          BMP's. Are you going to inform the farmers about the grant money they can recieve at

          these meetings?

 

         Response to   Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                                  3/21/2007

                                                                                                                                 6:03:00 AM

                Methane released as a greenhouse gas is worse than the carbon dioxide that is released

                when methane is burned.  Also, burning the methane that would be wasted is better than

                burning diesel fuel or gasoline.

               

                Yes, we were planning to inform farmers about the grant money at these meetings.

 

         Response from  Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                                  3/26/2007

                                                                                                                                 6:07:00 AM

                Referring to the comment made by FBI:

               

                I agree with your comment that Maryland is not self sufficient in their food production. 

                There are not many states that don't rely some on the food production of other states.

Comment from the Moderator.  Your point about most food production not being local is correct and important.  When making decisions on protecting the Bay, to what extent should you also consider the importance of maintaining the capacity to grow food locally (even if much of our food currently comes from far far away).  Once good farmland is used to "grow" houses, you can't go back to growing food.  Is that a good idea?  Does that make us - as a society - more or less secure?  If the answer is less secure, how to you ensure that good farmland stays in, or available for, agriculture?  People farm because they love to farm, but a lot of the farmer groups on this page exhibit frustration at being told they are "the problem" and being told what to do.  How do you keep them from throwing up their hands in frustration and selling off that good farmland for more money than they would ever make farming?   If you want to respond to this post, please put "to Moderator" at the top of the TQ.

 

 

Farmers

 

Caring Farmers of America Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                                   3/19/2007

                                                                                                                                   8:12:00 AM

We farmers believe that clean water would increase production of crops and food, which

would provide everyone with oppertunity of their needs. If everyone maintained there

agreement of their concern for the bay,we would have cleaner watersheds and a healthier

environment.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

   From:    Enigmatic Enviromentalists Broadway H.S. / Rissler

                                                                                                                               3/20/2007

                                                                                                                              12:51:00 PM

          What do you farmers do to help make the water clean? There are no details telling how

          you plan on increasing crop production. What is the agreement that everyone should

          maintain to help protect the bay and watersheds?

 

         Response to   Enigmatic Enviromentalists Broadway H.S. / Rissler

                                                                                                                                  3/21/2007

                                                                                                                                 7:55:00 AM

                We keep the water clean by controlling problems before we start. Before establishing crops

                and pasture management we would make sure that we are clear of are, and other

                watersheds around us. Making sure we have fresh is key to farmers. By puting toxins on

                plants, that soak into the ground then into the watershed, we are not only puting it into are

                own water that we use but into the water are livstock drinks too. 

 

  From: High on Life Homeowners Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

3/20/2007

8:04:00 AM

Your cows and your bug sparying gets in to the ground into the underground springs and runs off to are houses and lakes, we end uo drinking it or animals, we get sick, and the water goes bad, what are you going to do to stop this?

         Response from  Caring Farmers of America Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                                  3/22/2007

                                                                                                                                 7:58:00 AM

                Keep the cows and plant toxins away from the main areas of the springs. We have moved

                our crops and our pastures away form YOUR watershed. 

 

 

 

Farmers

 

The First Rich Farmers Moorefield H.S. / Gillies

                                                                                                                             3/20/2007

                                                                                                                             7:17:00 AM

Why are we important? - Farmers are important because America depends on farmers to

produce the goods they need to live their everyday lives.

 

Why do the bay's problems affect you? - They are affecting us by making people point fingers

at the farmers and placing blame on thoes who aren't the main source of the problem. Farmers

aren't the whole reason why the bay is being polluted.

 

How may you be affected by the possiable solutions? - Farmers are affected by the

government. By making farmers build composts, manure buildings, to hold feed, dead chickens,

and other things. This is costing the farmers large amounts of money. In the end, the buildings

dont amount to anything, and sooner or later the government and scientists will see that its not

all the farmers doing the polluting, its also the businesses, and factories.

 

Which types of solutions would you prefer? - Farmers and enviromentalists, would like to see

"earth friendly" pesticides insted of the ones being used now. They are causing large amounts

of harmful insecticides to be drained into the streams that sooner or later will empty into the

Bay.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Conkreat Jungul Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                             6:24:00 AM

         The problems are clearly stated in your paper, but how are you as a farmer going to

         contribute to the improvement of the bay?  The government asks farmers to build these

         structures to help with the quality of the bay.  Also farmers do contribute to a large

         amount of pollution in the bay.  Fertilizers and manure contribute to phosphorous,

         nitrogen and potassium levels in the water.  You may want to suggest ways to help reduce

         this pollution by using BMP’s (Riparian Buffers, Filter Strips, Field Boarders, etc.)

  From:    Chesapeake Industrial Corporation Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                             6:45:00 AM

         Most environmentally friendly practices implemented by the farmers also benefit the

         farmers. For example, the compost buildings mentioned could be used to trap the methane

          that is produced from the compost. The methane can be burned to create energy that the

          farmer can sell back to the power company. Also, there are many BMP's that cost money

         initially, but they benefit the farmers as well as the Bay.

 

 

         Response from  The First Rich Farmers Moorefield H.S. / Gillies

                                                                                                                                  3/23/2007

                                                                                                                                 7:21:00 AM

                We would like to first thank you for your "thoughtful" question.. We appriciate you

                commenting on our paper and we are taking your comments into consideration. We

                understand that the government is making these laws to help keep the bay clean but in the

                long run how is it REALLY going to help? Just by the farmers constructing a building isn't

                going to help the industries from dumping wastes into the small tributaries that then dump

                into the bay. Around here some farmers are pressed for money and dont have a lot to spend

                on "manure buildings" and "BMPs". Farmers may contritute to the Bay's pollution, but we're

                no the only ones!!

 

 

Farmers

 

Tenacious D Moorefield H.S. / Gillies

                                                                                                                             3/20/2007

                                                                                                                            7:30:00 AM

     The farmer is the important for all of our food. The bay laws can effect us farmers becuase

 they would have to spend more moeney to obey the laws in the bay. The Goverment will spend

more money to help the farmers then they would they bay. The solutions of us farmers perfer

were the goverment will come in and help build or to modify our farms to help the pay. The

water cycle could bring contaminets back up to the mountains to contaminate our water supply.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                              6:15:00 AM

         When you say that the water cycle could bring contaminants up mountains, what do you

         mean?  Where will the money come from to modify farms all throughout the Chesapeake

         Bay Watershed, who would implement these modifications, and what kind of

         modifications are you talking about? 

 

         Response from  Tenacious D Moorefield H.S. / Gillies

                                                                                                                                  3/23/2007

                                                                                                                                 7:46:00 AM

                We're sorry about that, we worded it out wrong. What we meant to say was. We did some

                more research and there are some fish that migrate along tha Atlantic coat as well as our

                Chesapeake Bay, they also end up migrating upstream sometimes into mountains, which

                would just bring it back.(Anguilla Rorstrata),The American Eel, is the 'fish' we're refuring to.

                The money can come from random non-profit organizations, donations, and the government

                also gives out grants to farmers, otherwise they help them out and cut out some of the more

                expensive things that the farmers can not afford. What we mean by modifications is

 

 

  From:  Anonymous Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                             6:50:00 AM

         Are you trying to say farmers spend lots of money on taxes, and the government should

         help with implementing BMPs on farms? If this is so, the government does provide grants

          for helping farmers.

 

 

Farmers

 

Farmer Friends of the Bay North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                             3/20/2007

                                                                                                                           10:48:00 AM

The farmer stake holder group is important because we contribute towards the economy.

Agriculture is the second largest industry in the state. The Maryland farmers are the reason

why we don't have to rely on other states for food which will lower our economy significantly.

Farmers are often blamed for the nutrient pollition that is in the Chesapeake Bay. They are

balamed because of the runoff. For the past 20 years farmers have been fine tuning best

management practices to control runoff. This is a huge cost to the farmers and the tax payers.

Farmers should continue with best mananment practicess.

The farmers are trying to manage their runoff levels by using runoff pitts or cover crops.

Many farmers use many different types of managment to control.

Home builders and home owners need to take more responsibility for the pollution problems.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/21/2007

                                                                                                                             6:22:00 AM

         You say that Maryland does not rely on other states for food because of their farmers. 

         Where do you get oranges, banana's and other food that does not grow in Maryland? 

         What types of BMP's are farmer's in Maryland using for pollution control?   

  From:    Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                             6:07:00 AM

         I agree that BMPs can be very costly.  So what type of support programs are there that

         can help pay farmers pay for them?

 

 

Farmers

 

Pitchfork of Justice Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                             3/21/2007

                                                                                                                            6:27:00 AM

We the farmers of Jefferson County WV. are striving to complete these few tasks that we

wish to accomplish. Some of which are to stop using disc instead of no-till drills because of

dust. We also need to use little or no pesticides because if it were to wash into the water, the

bay would be toxic which would kill the fish and if anyone were to drink the water they too

would then be intoxicted. It will be easy for us to fix this problem. We just stop using the

products completly and it would not hurt our income. We also are concerned about our friendly

cows polluting our water. We believe that just maybe we could make a diaper big enough to fit

on a cow. Thank you for your time and please respond.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                              6:17:00 AM

         While putting a diaper on a cow is an interesting solution, it is just not feasible.  First,

         how will you dispose of used diapers without causing pollution?  Second, won’t the

         factories that make the diapers create further pollution?  Finally, how will a farm

         manage to change the diapers of 300 or more cows?  Also, concerning your other

         solution, how do you plan to convince people to stop using all products?

    From the Moderator.  I just want to add to Blankenship's comment.  Cattle manure is an essential resource on farms and, except in a concentrated feeding area setting, helps build the organic matter and nutrients necessary for good soil on pasture, hay, and croplands.  The issue is management of the cattle so the manure stays away from streams.  How might you do that?

     

 

Farmers

 

the farmers Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                             3/21/2007

                                                                                                                            6:56:00 AM

we came up with the  idea for farmers to stop using harmful Pesticides and fertilizers on there

crops, because it causes pollution when it runs down into the water Contaminating the water

and killing fish and plants.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Farmers and Landowners Cooperative Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                             6:06:00 AM

         Well, those are both wonderful ideas. However, the idea behind this forum is to find

         ways for all stakeholders to work together to find solutions. All stakeholders cause some

         form of pollution, how can we all help?

 

 

Farmers

 

Future Farmers of Jefferson County Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                             3/21/2007

                                                                                                                            8:07:00 AM

   Farmers are important. We supply food. Farmers also have a major affect on the quality of

water. Also, a major part of Jefferson County's economy consists on farming and agriculture.

   We supply alot of things. If there weren't any animals there would be no food. Some

examples of the food we wouldn't have are: cows, chicken, turkey, pigs, goat, etc.

   The ways we could help is to use bio-diesel in our tractors, keep our animals clean, and keep

them out of local streams and creeks.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Fishing and Boating Industries (F.B.I.) Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School /

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                             6:35:00 AM

         Farmer's do have a huge impact on the quality of water.  Using bio-diesel in tractor's is

         a great idea.  Do you have any plans on ways to prevent runoff and pollution into local

         streams.  Maybe a riparian buffer or filter strip?

 

 

Farmers

 

Sustainable Futures Aberdeen H.S. / McDonough

                                                                                                                             3/22/2007

                                                                                                                           11:38:00 AM

       As farmers the actions we take not only affect our area but the entire world. Being part of

the Chesapeake Bay Watershed, we need to be even more aware of our actions and their

consequences. The number of farms in Maryland has been declining in the past years, while

farm production costs have been on a rise. It is not that we’re unwilling to implement changes

to save and preserve our environment, but that we are unable to complete such a gigantic task

quickly due to financial limitations. Nitrogen and phosphorous pollution are big problems in the

 bay and we, the farmers of Maryland, contribute over 40% of it. Pesticides and fertilizers are

 also growing problems. What we do to the water eventually comes back to us either through the

 water cycle or the food chain. As fish and other aquatic life are killed off by the

contaminants we release from the farms, the price of certain foods will increase drastically as

they become scarce, further deepening our financial crisis. Health hazards could also arise

from the chemicals we use as we are slowly poisoning ourselves through the water. Our state

government has been made aware of this problem and is proposing plans to remove the

Chesapeake Bay off of the EPA’s “dirty waters” list. Farmers are one of their biggest focuses

since agricultural runoff, such as fertilizer and sediments is the largest contributor to water

pollution. Proposed changes include cover crops, alternative crops, crop rotation, buffers and

wetlands, manure management, and will have a drastic effect on our way of life but are

necessary to ensure our future on this planet. The biggest problem is acquiring the needed

money since these solutions will not be cheap to implement but as long as we have everyone’s

support we can achieve our goal for a cleaner future!

 

References:

 

Young, T.F.,Ph.D., & Congdon, C.H. (n.d.). Plowing New Ground. Retrieved March 20, 2007, from

 http://www.environmentaldefense.org/documents/1950_farmpollutionplowingexec.htm

 

Lefebvre, B. (Nov. 11, 2005). CBF Asks the State of Maryland to Invest $120 Million ANnually

in Agriculture. Retrieved March 20, 2007, from

http://www.cbf.org/site/News2?page=NewsArticle&id=12953&security=1&news_iv_ctrl=108

2%20%20%20&JServSessionIdr004=4q8zklss16.app23a

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

 

 

Farmers

 

dgaf08 Aberdeen H.S. / McDonough

                                                                                                                             3/22/2007

                                                                                                                           11:43:00 AM

Agricultural Cultivators possess versatile stakes within the changing ecosystem of the

Chesapeake Bay area. Environmental inhibitors that affect the soil have a direct impact on the

quantity of stable crop produced.  Obviously farmers are very important to our society.  As a

part of this community we must be more aware of the methods that we use to grow our crops. 

We need to realize that specifically in Harford County; the Chesapeake Bay is gradually

becoming more polluted.  Pesticides and sediments that enter the bay from point sources or non

point sources are becoming a problem for residents around the Bay.  Sedimentation occurs

when wind or water runoff carries soil particles from an area, such as a farm field, and

transports them to a water body, such as a stream or lake. Excessive sedimentation clouds the

water, which reduces the amount of sunlight reaching aquatic plants and damages the Bay. As

farmers, we understand that nutrients such as phosphorus, nitrogen, and potassium in the form

of fertilizers manure, and crop residues are applied to enhance production. We also feel it is

our duty to implement nutrient management plans which help maintain high yields and save

money on the use of fertilizers while reducing pollution.  We need to try to confine our areas

efficiently with the space we have. We can reduce pollution from irrigation by improving

water use efficiently. To reduce the impacts of grazing on water quality, we as farmers can

keep livestock out of sensitive areas and provide alternative sources of water and shade.

Managing these aspects positively can help flip the negative effects of the Bay in our

community.  Farmers have a sole responsibility to protect our ecosystem, specifically the bay

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

 

 

Farmers

 

Freaky Farmer Aberdeen H.S. / McDonough

                                                                                                                             3/22/2007

                                                                                                                           11:43:00 AM

I live near a soybean farm plot, several corn fields and a cow farm. The fields rotate every

now and then, but for most of the season the fields remain barren of everything but corn, and

right now they are barren of anything green. All the properties nearby are supplied by well

water, including the farmer’s. Some people use several chemicals for their lawns and this ends

up in both the well water and on the corn fields. Runoff is becoming an ever increasing problem

 as ground cover and trees are being removed for development. The riparian buffer is non-

existent. As chemicals are added to the crops, they join the water source and reemerge from

our wells, water used in our homes and on the fields. Chemicals will eventually run into the bay

and negatively impact ecosystems, but first they will enter our bodies and harm us. Steps must

be taken now to stop this poisoning.

Within this area are many acres of land, and more space must be devoted to ground cover,

shrubs, trees as we need ecological filters. The first step to changing this landscape should be

from the county government, lifting restrictions upon grass height of lawns and thus providing

potential aide. Instead of measuring the heights of lawns they should be allowed them to grow

and filter runoff. Even this simple step would have great effect if instituted county-wide. By

not using lawn-mowers so often, less oil is used and potentially spilled, less air pollution is

emitted and we help all the animals in the area, including ourselves. The step is easy, not hard to

 enforce and best of all, saves you money; no one is hurt and everyone benefits. We can make

some green by growing some green. So why are we still enforcing pointless, harmful laws?

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/31/2007

                                                                                                                             7:08:00 AM

         Okay, first of all, should the government be the first to act? What motivations are there

         for the local government to change their laws and regulations in regards to the Bay?

         Wouldn’t it be better for the individuals to start new techniques? It might be easier for

         individual farmers to find motivation than the local government.

 

 

Farmers

 

The supreme amazing people that do good stuff Jefferson H.S. / Gipson

                                                                                                                             3/22/2007

                                                                                                                           12:24:00 PM

Pollution is bad for the animals in the bay, we should only be killing them by devouring them in a

 resturant, also the bay is a good resource for water

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    T.A.L.K About the Bay Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                              6:41:00 AM

         Thank you for enlightening everyone on the fact that pollution is indeed bad for the

         animals in the Chesapeake Bay and the bay itself.  Also, if we’re not mistaken you are

         supposed to be a farmer stakeholder group, but you fail to mention anything regarding

         steps farmers can take to help the condition of the bay, including riparian buffers and

         other BMP’s (Best Management Practices).  In addition, the bay will not be a good source

          of water, since in fact the water in the bay is brackish (mixture of salt water and fresh

         water).  So, unless you have plans of implementing desalinization plants, the water taken

         from the bay will not be “good.”  Overall, good ideas, but plan before you act, it will save

         you greater heart ache in the future.  

        

         Here are some resources to help:Buffer Strips -

         http://www.nrcs.usda.gov/FEATURE/buffers/

         Water Quality   -  http://www.chesapeakebay.net/wquality.htm

 

  From:    Anonymous Hampshire H.S. / Moore

                                                                                                                              3/27/2007

                                                                                                                            10:46:00 AM

         Yes we know that pollution is bad, but how are we going to correct it? How can the bay

         be a good resource for water when you can not even drink it? Also you even said it

         yourself that the bay is already polluted so how can it be a good resource for water?

 

 

Farmers

RS Farmers Moorefield H.S. / Gillies

                                                                                                                             3/23/2007

                                                                                                                            7:23:00 AM

Why, you may ask, are farmers important? The answer is that we are very important! We

supply our area, the county, and the world with food and food biproducts. The bay and its

watershed are just as, if not more, important to us as they are to everyone else. We can really

affect the bay by the way we conduct ourselves as well as our farm. We need to watch the way

we fertlize our fields, graze our cattle, and dispose of our waste. If we don't watch what we

are doing the government may pass very restrictive laws govrning the way that we can run our

farms. This is not the way that we would like to see it go, we would much rather just fix the

wrong things we are doing by ourselves without problems will cost money but it is worth it in the

 long run! What it all comes down to is that we all need to work together to clean up and keep

clean the bay and its watershed.

 

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                             6:29:00 AM

         How do you plan to convince other farmers to use different practices if they will cost

         more money? Are farmers more likely to change their habits without the laws and

         regulations enforcing their actions? I agree that everyone needs to work together, but

            without monetary incentive of some kind, people in general will not change their habits. 

  From:    CBJL East Hardy H.S. / Halterman

                                                                                                                              3/26/2007

                                                                                                                            10:55:00 AM

         Yes we know that pollution is bad, but how are we going to correct it? How can the bay

         be a good resource for water when you can not even drink it? Also you even said it

         yourself that the bay is already polluted so how can it be a good resource for water?

 

 

 

Farmers

 

Hampshire Rednecks Hampshire H.S. / Moore

                                                                                                                             3/26/2007

                                                                                                                            8:20:00 AM

Farmers are always having the figures being pointed at them. Us farmers are tired of it. Yeah

we may pollute the streams but with out the farmers in the World there would be no food and

everyone would die of starvation.  Farmers are getting tired of every body blaming it all on the

farmers. People in the World need to start blaming it on factories and other engineering

companies because the on thing that is killing the birds is the oil in the streams and rivers.  If

the farmers were to have good field the was not sold off and put into a subdivision the the

problem would be solved because we would have more land to make hay and feed cattle and

other farm animals because with out the farms everyone would be out of luck. So stop blaming

the Farmers!!!

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Happy Campers North Harford H.S. / OLeary

                                                                                                                              3/28/2007

                                                                                                                            12:00:00 PM

         I understand you are stressed over the fact that everyone blames the farmers, however,

         that is not the point of this forum. The idea is not to point fingers, but to focus on how

         to fix the issue. Examples on your part could be planting trees around your farm as a

         riparian buffer. Do you have any other ideas concerning stakeholders as a group

         improving the Bay? Harford County is a very rural area, however, the farmers here do

         not dwell on how they'e blamed, they have become stewards of the Bay.

        

         Try this link for Best Management practices:

        

         http://cacaponinstitute.org/WVPTS%20bmps.htm

 

 

Farmers

 

Robbie Jennifer Justin James Wood H.S. / Fordyce

                                                                                                                             3/26/2007

                                                                                                                            8:20:00 AM

1.  We're important to the Chesapeake Bay because we provide food for the people who live

there and the soil is enriched from our crops "remains" and the other animals manure.  2.  The

bay's problems affect us because the livestock are drinking from the river that is polluted.

Also, it is loaded with pollutants from urban and suburban areas. But we also are the ones who

fertilize the crops and our cow and animals walk through the water leaving manure and

fertilizer from the fields.  3.  The solutions proposed will change our farming life by the

animals and cows will not be able to get in the water to cool off in the summer, and will not be

able to get anything to drink unless we provide water for them in the troughs, which would take

time out of my busy schedule. It could also kill our animals and crops, therefore, make me go

bankrupt.  4.  Our group is willing to put water filters on our property to filter out the

"harmful" chemicals that our farms produce. Let less dumping of harmful chemicals.  The only

cost that these solutions cause would be the price of the troughs, the costs of the filters if they

 are proposed, and time. We would have to give up time doing other things and the use of our

stream/pond.  The solutions benefit me directly because I don't have to worry about the crops

getting any water, nutrients, etc. But also it will provide other people with healthier water, and

other resources from the watershed. If they would like us to participate in this conservation,

they should provide us, and install the needed elements to our property with little to no charge

to us.  The solution should be proposed so the people and animals on the farms are healthier.

Less damage to out crops would make more money in return. If all farmers disappeared then

other people would end up dying and disappearing as well. Since farmers produce crops and

food, such as: beef, eggs, wheat, corn, watermelon, veggies, fruit, milk, etc.

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions

 

  From:    Blankenship Development Massanutten Reg. Gvnrs. School / Newcomer

                                                                                                                              3/31/2007

                                                                                                                              7:14:00 AM

         You are right about the importance of farmers; without them America would go hungry.

         The expression “time is money” is especially true for you, but once you made the changes

          to your farm, you might be able to save money from government grants or tax cuts due

         to your use of environmentally friendly methods. You have good ideas and seem to be on

         the right track with your thinking.

 

 

Farmers

 

LC Hampshire H.S. / Moore

                                                                                                                             3/27/2007

                                                                                                                            11:12:00 AM

As farmers we are very important to the world. We know that we are one of the main sources

for food but also a main source for pollution. We think that not just us a whole but as a

community we can help prevent water pollution. We know we can't do it alone, but just a little

effort could help. It would be easier if all of us raised money and donated it to buy water

purifiers. But also instead of using all those chemicals for farming, why not just use manure

from your own farm? It would be simplier and easier in all ways! And it would also save money.

We believe that if everyone pitched in a little bit it would help and it could make a huge

difference!!!

 

 

Ask this stakeholder a Thoughtful Question or Respond


Thoughtful Questions