The Potomac Highlands Watershed School 

"Oh Deer!" Environmental Forum

Points of View with Thoughtful Questions - The Forest

If you landed here via a search engine, this page is part of Cacapon Institute's web school.  Our home page is here.

 

The Forest POV & TQ Navigation

5    The_Forest    3

Navigation to other POV pages

farmer, hunter, forester, homeowner, insurance company, Others, Forum Home

 

School: Hampshire High School/  Class: 1st Block Environmental Science
Teacher: Mr. Moore
POV Group Name: 5
Date: 11/08/2006/  Time: 08:23 AM

If the deer population is left alone then they could destroy the small vegetation. We could install deer fences in differnt areas around the county. We could also raise deer farms to keep them in an enclosed area so that they don't not destroy a lot of the forest. We have to take care of the forest so it can grow healthy and strong. If we focus on the deer population only, then the rest of the forest will suffer. The forest will provide enough sustanence for only a certain amont of life, the rest will die, but that is how the forest and nature works.


Thoughtful_Question

From: forester/  Class_Name: vo ag 1/  Teacher: Mr. Halterman/  School: EHHS/  Date: Tuesday, November 14, 2006/  Time: 01:10 PM

This occurence is a part of the circle lif why would you want to destroy it or contrl it


From: The Forest/  Class_Name: Vo. Agriculture 1/  Teacher: Mr. Halterman/  School: EHHS/  Date: Tuesday, November 14, 2006/  Time: 01:14 PM

What are you planning to feed the deer in their little area once they eat all the food? New trees will probably not be able to germinate in time to support the growing population of deer.

The Forest POV & TQ Navigation

5    The_Forest    3

Back to Top

 

 

School: Hampshire High School/  Class: 2nd Block Enironmental Science
Teacher: Mr. Moore
POV Group Name: The Forest
Date: 11/08/2006/  Time: 10:27 AM

As the forest, we are concerned about the overall impact of the deer. We are worried that once the older trees begin to die out, there will no longer be younger trees because the deer will have eaten all of the under story, leaving no trees to take over once the older trees die.. The forest will be dead. We can not allow this. People have been trying to find solutions to our forest problem for the past decade. The deer are out of control and something needs to be done! If nothing is done soon, West Virginia will no longer be “almost heaven.” Instead it will just be a barren wasteland of dirt and rocks. So we have decided on a few things that we could do to control the deer population in the area. These factors will hopefully prove to make a difference in the environment of this area. The first thing that could be done would be to extend hunting season by a few months, or maybe even for the whole year. And also make the extended season include male and female deer alike. This would deplete the deer population so that the forest could begin to heal itself. Another factor that could be added to the forest could be mountain lions that would control deer population and add predators to the area. The lions would eat the deer, reducing the population, and we wouldn’t have to worry about over-population of lions because they would die off as the deer population, the food source, depletes. Now we go onto some solutions for preserving the trees in the area. We can encase saplings in PVC-like pipes. We have found in our area that doing this does in fact protect the tree until it is old enough to take a beating from the deer population without dying. We have been doing this to trees in our area recently and it has proven to actually help the trees survive. There are also ways that you can protect around your house too. Around the woods of your house, you can place deer fencing, which is a 7-8 foot plastic-material, around the area in which you want to protect. You can also induce a chemical smell into the woods or area around your house to keep the deer out, as well. These are a few ways that we have decided to try to control the population in the woods in our area. Doing these things will improve the state of the forests in the area, and will allow the under story to grow up after the older trees begin to die off. Hopefully these ideas and suggestions from others will make the future of our forests a positive one and not negative.


Thoughtful Questions

From: The Homeowners /  Class_Name: Environmental Science 2/  Teacher: Mrs. O'Leary/  School: North Harford High School/  Date: Tuesday, November 14, 2006/  Time: 12:55 PM

Though you provide an interesting perspective, did you even consider that encasing trees with PVC pipes would hinder the aesthetic value of the forest, which is own of the main reasons people move to the country? Also, with the chemical smell idea, do you really want to spray your house and land with chemicals? I highly doubt the deer will be all that is affected by the smell.


From: hampshire 4th block/  Class_Name: vo-ag. 1/  Teacher: halterman/  School: ehhs/  /  Date: Tuesday, November 14, 2006/  Time: 01:27 PM

How can you put a "substance" on the trees without harming the other ecosystems living in those trees? You have to think of the other animals as well, and you have to think of how the "chemical pill" effects the environment also like; the ozone layer when burning the trees for homes, but it is good that you thought of the downside of putting fences up, and it is good that you realized the cost problem of the "tree birthing place". I liked reading yours(one student to an other). sorry, i like to put things in to my own words

The Forest POV & TQ Navigation

5    The_Forest    3

Back to Top

 

School: EHHS/  Class: Vo-Agriculture
Teacher: Mr. Arthur Halterman
POV Group Name: 3
Date: 11/08/2006/  Time: 01:51 PM

Too many deer cause too many problems, even for themselves. The number of deer in Hardy County has risen in past years. The deer are eating themselves out of their own home. The deer population is getting out of control, and if the people of this region do not do anything about it the deer will soon destroy the forest vegetation and soon the forest itself. The over population of deer is a hazard to the forests of West Virginia, and to the farmers who use the land of West Virginia. The deer of this region are eating all the tree seedling growing on the forest ground, and without new tree seedlings there will not be any new trees growing to provide oxygen to humans and to the other animals on this earth. There are several ways to prevent the overpopulation of deer growth and deer destroying the habitat. One way to prevent the deer from overpopulating and destroying the forests is to increase the limit of deer killings during the hunting seasons in the fall. This will prevent more deer from breeding and producing more offspring during the spring. By increasing the limit this will provide more chances for hunters to get more meat to provide for their families during the winter. Another way to prevent overpopulation is to fence off all the areas that are being affected by the deer. Fencing is not harmful to the deer nor is it killing the deer, the deer will eat less of the forest and have less of a chance to find new mates for the fall season; decreasing the population, and giving the seedlings on the other side of the fence a chance to grow. One advantage of fencing off the deer is that scientists get to study the deer, and their habits, and the scientists get to study the re-growth of the new forest plants growing in the fenced off areas of the forest. There are plenty of ways to prevent the overpopulation of deer without slaughtering them, but we as humans must figure out a way how the humans and the animals can co-exist in the space that we have been given.


The Forest POV & TQ Navigation

5    The_Forest    3

Back to Top